Overview of Generac GP17500E

The Generac 5735 GP17500E is a robust 17500-Watt gas-powered portable generator known for its reliability and power. With the capability to provide backup power suitable for homes and jobsites, this generator is equipped with a high-performing OHVI engine that ensures extended run times.

The unparalleled power of this generator is attributed to its 992cc OHVI engine. Its efficient features such as an hour meter for tracking usage, a low-oil level shutdown for engine protection, and idle control to reduce noise and conserve fuel, contribute to its optimal performance.

In terms of durability, the GP17500E stands out with its hardened 1-1/4″ steel tube cradle. The generator is not only robust but also portable, thanks to its integrated lifting eye which makes transport easy and secure.

• Brand: Generac
• Wattage: 17500 watts
• Fuel Type: Gasoline
• Power Source: Gas-powered
• Recommended Uses For Product: Security
• Item Weight: 390 Pounds
• Voltage: 120 Volts
• Output Wattage: 17500 Watts
• Special Feature: Electric
• Included Components: Generator

Feature	Description
Unmatched Power	Equipped with a robust 992cc OHVI engine, providing reliable and consistent power
Convenient Electric Start	Includes battery with plug-in battery charger jack for convenience and peace of mind
Enhanced Features for Efficiency	Equipped with an hour meter, low-oil level shutdown, and idle control to enhance performance
Extended Run Time	Provides up to 10 hours of run time at 50% load thanks to its 16-gallon fuel tank
Durable and Transportable	Featuring a hardened 1-1/4″ steel tube cradle for durability and integrated lifting eye for easy transport

The Generac GP17500E is priced at $3,649.00.

Overview of DuroStar DS13000E

The DuroStar DS13000E is a gas-powered portable generator that offers 13,000 starting watts and 10,500 running watts. It is designed to handle heavy loads, making it a reliable choice for backing up home power, running high voltage appliances, or powering high amperage power tools.

At the heart of the DS13000E is a 500cc OHV engine, which provides the necessary power for various tasks. The generator also features an idle control function, which reduces the RPMs when not in use, thereby saving fuel and reducing noise. This feature makes it ideal for jobsites where power is used intermittently.

To ensure the longevity of the generator, the DS13000E is equipped with a low oil shutoff feature. When the oil level is low, the generator automatically shuts off, protecting your investment. Furthermore, the generator comes with a fully featured power panel that includes a variety of outlets for maximum compatibility.

• Brand: DuroStar
• Wattage: 13000 watts
• Fuel Type: Gasoline
• Power Source: Gas-Powered
• Item Weight: 234 Pounds
• Voltage: 12 Volts
• Output Wattage: 13000 Watts
• Special Feature: Electric
• Included Components: Generator
• Color: Red/Black

Feature	Description
Plenty of Power	Offers 13,000 starting watts and 10,500 running watts to handle heavy loads
Powerful Engine	Powered by a 500cc OHV engine that can handle multiple jobs
Idle Control	Lowers the RPMs of the generator when not in use, saving fuel and reducing noise
Low Oil Shutoff	Automatically shuts the generator off when it senses that the oil is low
Fully Featured Power Panel	Includes a variety of outlets for maximum compatibility, a digital voltmeter, and a 12V automotive charging outlet

The DuroStar DS13000E is priced at $999.00.

Summary Table of Generac GP17500E and DuroStar DS13000E Specifications

Specification	Generac GP17500E	DuroStar DS13000E
Brand	Generac	DuroStar
Wattage	17500 watts	13000 watts
Fuel Type	Gasoline	Gasoline
Power Source	Gas-powered	Gas-Powered
Item Weight	390 Pounds	234 Pounds
Voltage	120 Volts	12 Volts
Output Wattage	17500 Watts	13000 Watts
Special Feature	Electric	Electric
Color	N/A	Red/Black
Price	$3,649.00	$999.00

User reviews of Generac GP17500E

Positive Reviews Summary for Generac GP17500E

• Users appreciate the thoughtful changes made to the Generac GP17500E model, including an elapsed-hours meter and a retainer string on the gas cap that prevents it from being lost during refueling.
• The generator’s built quality and performance are highly praised by users, including its ability to handle high power needs. It is seen as a reliable solution during power outages, even for extended periods.
• Many users have found the Generac GP17500E to be more cost-effective compared to installing a full-house model with corresponding gas piping.
• Customers have noted the impressive power output of the Generac GP17500E, with some even likening it to the “F350 of pickup trucks”. This generator is capable of running an entire house, including heavy-duty appliances like air conditioning units and heat pumps.
• The Generac GP17500E is often praised for its longevity and reliability, with several users noting that their generators have been working flawlessly for years.
• Users have also appreciated the generator’s fuel efficiency when running on low load, making it a practical choice for long-term power outages.
• Some users have found the generator to be fairly quiet for its size, while others have made adjustments to further reduce noise levels.
• Despite its size and weight, users have found ways to easily move and store the generator. Suggestions from users include replacing the stock tires and adding a swivel caster for easier maneuverability.

Negative Aspects of Generac GP17500E

• Several users complained about the generator’s reliability, with many reports of it failing or breaking down after a short period of use.
• The 17.5 kW model uses the same stator as the 15 kW model, causing it to fail right after the warranty period according to some users.
• Many users found the generator to be extremely loud.
• Starting the generator was reported to be difficult due to an uncalibrated choke throttle. Some users even reported killing the battery in the process of trying to start it.
• Some users reported issues with the oil leaking from the sensor and oil cooler lines.
• Several complaints were made about fuel leakage from the exhaust and fuel shut-off.
• There were reports of the generator failing to power house appliances fully, specifically air conditioning units.
• Several users mentioned receiving the generator with a dead battery that was not covered by the warranty.
• Some users reported the generator was delivered with oil and battery acid leaks, causing damage to the unit.
• The customer service of Generac received heavy criticism for being unhelpful and indifferent to the problems faced by users.

User reviews of DuroStar DS13000E

Summary of Positive User Reviews for DuroStar DS13000E

• Performing reliably even after 100 hours of use, the DuroStar DS13000E is recognized for its steady functionality. Users appreciated its ability to power an entire home, with the exception of central air conditioning systems.
• The generator’s maintenance requirements are straightforward and manageable with users suggesting tips such as the use of a Fumoto Drain valve for easier oil changes. Regular maintenance, such as oil changes every 20 hours, appears to contribute to the machine’s reliable performance.
• The DuroStar DS13000E is a practical choice for people in areas prone to power outages, like Texas. Users have successfully used it to power up their electric cars or run their entire house, including air conditioning.
• Despite being a bit louder than a lawn mower, users still find the noise level acceptable considering the generator’s performance and value for money.
• Even though some users reported minor issues like the gas tank gauge sticking and the grounding post being small, these did not significantly impact the overall positive experience with the generator.
• Another noteworthy point is the generator’s impressive fuel efficiency, with one user getting a full 8 hours of runtime out of a single tank of gas.

Summary of critical user reviews of DuroStar DS13000E

• Unfortunately, the DuroStar DS13000E has received a number of critical reviews. Many users have reported issues with the generator’s reliability, stating it often fails to start or run smoothly.
• Additionally, there are complaints about the product’s durability. Some users claim that the generator breaks down frequently and requires constant maintenance and repairs.
• Noisy operation is another problem raised by users. According to the reviews, the DS13000E is significantly louder than other models in the same price range.
• Lastly, several users have reported poor customer service experiences with DuroStar, stating that they received little to no assistance when facing issues with the generator.

Pros and Cons of the compared products

Pros and Cons of Generac GP17500E

Pros	Cons
Includes thoughtful features like an elapsed-hours meter and a retainer string on the gas cap.	Some users reported reliability issues, with the generator failing or breaking down after a short use period.
High-quality build and performance praised by users, able to handle high power needs reliably.	Uses the same stator as the 15 kW model, which could potentially fail right after the warranty period.
More cost-effective compared to installing a full-house model with corresponding gas piping.	Starting the generator can be difficult due to an uncalibrated choke throttle, potentially killing the battery in the process.
Impressive power output able to run an entire house, including heavy-duty appliances.	Some users experienced oil leakage from the sensor and oil cooler lines.
Longevity and reliability, with several users noting flawless operation for years.	Reports of fuel leakage from the exhaust and fuel shut-off.
Fuel efficient when running on low load, making it a practical choice for long-term power outages.	Some users reported the generator failed to fully power house appliances, especially air conditioning units.
Despite its size, it can be fairly quiet and easy to maneuver with user modifications.	Complaints about receiving the generator with a dead battery not covered by the warranty, and units delivered with oil and battery acid leaks causing damage.
	Generac’s customer service received heavy criticism for being unhelpful and indifferent to users’ problems.

Pros and Cons of DuroStar DS13000E

Pros	Cons
Recognized for steady functionality, reliably performing even after 100 hours of use.	Reliability issues reported by users, with the generator often failing to start or run smoothly.
Maintenance requirements are straightforward and manageable with users suggesting helpful tips.	Concerns about the product’s durability with frequent breakdowns and constant maintenance and repairs needed.
Practical for areas prone to power outages, successfully used to power up entire houses and electric cars.	Noisier operation compared to other models in the same price range.
Noise level is acceptable considering the performance and value for money, despite being louder than a lawn mower.	Poor customer service experiences reported by users, with little to no assistance provided.
Minor issues like gas tank gauge sticking and small grounding post did not significantly impact the positive user experience.
Impressive fuel efficiency, with one user reporting a full 8 hours of runtime out of a single tank of gas.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the choice between the Generac GP17500E and DuroStar DS13000E will largely depend on your specific needs. If you require a generator with a higher wattage and extended run time, the Generac GP17500E is a solid choice. However, if you’re looking for a more affordable option with a lighter weight, the DuroStar DS13000E is a worthy contender. It’s important to consider the specifications of each generator, such as the wattage, fuel type, power source, and special features, in order to choose the right product for your needs.